Getting Hernandez, the only thing missing of respectable consensual unions was legitimately binding approve of one’s state

For some reason my proposition happens contrary to the earliest and you can standard institution from relationship, however, no matter if we’re in favor of relationships, as is installing of males exactly who make guidelines for people, we wish to quietly think man’s genuine condition. Considering that law comes regarding reality, this type of guys possess united right here to write a constitution and therefore wipes brush the new errors of history and you can tries another roadway money for hard times, [thus] it’s important which they judiciously data new conditions of our own landscaping and you will arrive at the finish there are things inside our life plus our society that we cannot inside in whatever way close the eyes, we need certainly to deal with valiantly. 51

Of the asserting one to an effective disjuncture resided ranging from legislators’ beliefs and you can “societal fact,” Hernandez debated that she is attacking for Cubans who had been not aren’t said to be type intimate propriety and you will, for this reason, was unjustly disenfranchised

We have arrive at the System to help you meagerly guard, towards the good my element, the new Cuban girl, new partnered lady, the fresh single lady, the new white girl, the brand new black woman, girls of all of the classes. I want to say that there is a large number of Cuban ladies in tough and you can awkward things, that are once the respectable and also as worth merit as the are other ladies, that simply since the this woman is in a free of charge partnership, does not always mean that individuals should consider the lady and her friends depraved. 52

Hernandez reasoned that mere legal sanction regarding an intimate relationship you’ll not the sole facts that a person is actually a genuine and you may moral citizen

Twenty-a couple of from the sixty-half dozen System users browsing the brand new training voted in order to approve Hernandez’s proposal. A lot of individuals who chosen for the favor reasoned which do assist males inside the consensual unions to meet up with a similar commitments and obligations you to definitely married men was destined to see and you will, hence, carry out include every woman and children. Such, modern Construction associate Capablanca contended you to “though it [Hernandez’s modification] looks paradoxical, far from getting…an attack on relationships, it is a shelter of it.” 53 He informed me, “When men remember that they are guilty of women which have which he’s a great consensual partnership and also for the youngsters one to influence from these 100 % free unions, chances are they cannot engage in consensual unions however in relationships.” 54 Capablanca illustrated men due to the fact almost naturally irresponsible, and you will intended that ladies requisite State defense against them. Anyone else echoed their rationale.

But not, more Set up players, progressives and you will traditionals, balked at the Hernandez’s idea, arguing it absolutely was maybe not conducive so you can democratic progress and you will manage grant legal rights and rights to undeserving, depraved citizens. Antique System affiliate Cortina led an effective competing challenge facing Hernandez’s proposal, framing his dissent since a combat to possess modernity, progress, and society. The guy said that an effective constitutional guarantee to take on consensual unions similar so you can judge marriage ceremonies create essentially upload Cuba out-of towards an appropriate road divergent regarding regarding “all civilized regions on earth” and you may “damage…the fresh matrimonial program, and then make [it] entirely useless.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “When it amendment have been approved, we may write a large dilemma for the judge married life, and in addition we carry out do the outcomes of governmental wave and that i’ve merely lived as a consequence of, so you can groups of your psychological and you may family members lifetime, [sectors] which don’t need to be turned on radical and you will perturbing method in which was advised.” 56 Having Cortina, the fresh new 1933 wave is actually a political revolution, and you will then change should simply affect politics: Public things might be remaining alone.